Authors: Pengfei Zhang, Jinghua Gao Title: Unequal nursing: the impact of China’s public health insurance on nursing services for older adults (2025)
Review:
Zhang and Gao's article presents a rigorous empirical investigation into how China's public health insurance system affects access to nursing services among older adults, revealing a central paradox: while insurance improves utilization, its fragmented structure perpetuates inequality. Drawing on data from the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study (2018 and 2020) and employing logistic regression models, the authors analyze both insurance participation and insurance type as determinants of outpatient and inpatient care utilization among individuals aged 60 and above.
The study's findings are striking. Participation in public health insurance increases the likelihood of using nursing services by 53.57%, with even stronger effects for inpatient care (63.07%). However, significant disparities emerge between insurance schemes: older adults enrolled in the Urban Employee Basic Medical Insurance (UEBMI) are 26.49% more likely to access nursing services than those covered by the Urban-Rural Resident Basic Medical Insurance (URRBMI). The authors attribute this gap to structural differences in funding—UEBMI benefits from mandatory employer-employee contributions generating higher reimbursement rates, while URRBMI relies on government subsidies with more limited coverage—as well as differences in access to higher-level medical institutions. Health-related factors emerge as the primary drivers of service utilization, while socioeconomic factors show no significant effects, suggesting that insurance effectively decommodifies access for those who are covered.
The theoretical framework draws on welfare state theory, particularly Esping-Andersen's concept of decommodification, complemented by analyses of income effects and moral hazard. The methodology is sound, with appropriate controls for demographic characteristics, health status, and economic resources. However, limitations include reliance on self-reported data with potential recall bias, the broad definition of "nursing services," and the possibility of unobserved confounding factors despite controls. The COVID-19 pandemic's impact on 2020 data is acknowledged but not fully explored.
The authors propose practical policy recommendations, including increasing URRBMI reimbursement rates, expanding coverage to uninsured populations, eliminating status-based discrimination through gradual benefit harmonization, and investing in rural healthcare infrastructure through telemedicine and incentives for medical professionals. The recognition that rural older adults face additional barriers—limited health literacy, geographic distance, and concentrated urban medical resources—demonstrates nuanced understanding of the multidimensional nature of healthcare inequality.
This study has significant implications beyond China, challenging simplistic metrics focused solely on coverage rates and demonstrating that insurance quality and generosity are equally critical for achieving health equity. While the study effectively illuminates the tension between expanding coverage and avoiding entrenched disparities, future research could benefit from longitudinal analysis tracking changes in inequality over time and qualitative exploration of the lived experiences of older adults navigating different insurance systems. Overall, Zhang and Gao have produced a valuable contribution to health policy research, offering evidence-based insights for both Chinese health system reform and international comparative analysis.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12912-025-03459-1


